5 hotels with a Michelin Key or another recognised award, and 1 selected on guest score. Compare them by area, guest score, facilities and price.
6 hotels
One Baha Mar Blvd.
A guest liked“Choice of restaurants, good staffing ratios , lovely beach”
A guest disliked“Some staff lacked adequate training re customer service but overall most were good.”
Rate found Oct 2026: free cancellation.Full profile of Rosewood Baha Mar: rooms, photos and reviews
Highest guest score on this list: 9.0 from 161 reviews. Guests rate the location 8.5, second-highest here.
Mahogany Hill, Western Road PO Box N-7776-78, Nassau, Bahamas
A guest liked“Tasteful and beautiful decor, gorgeous architecture and style. Excellent food at all the dining options. Very friendly and helpful staff. The beach through Old Fort Bay Club is the most beautiful on the island.”
A guest disliked“Very expensive just for water and sun screen”
Rate found Oct 2026: free cancellation.Full profile of The Island House: rooms, photos and reviews
Second-highest guest score on this list: 8.8 from 54 reviews. Guests rate the location 9.9, the highest here.
ConsiderOnly 54 guest reviews so far
The Pink Mermaid, Beach Bar
Chapel Street, Harbour Island, Bahamas
A guest liked“I liked everything. It was so charming and the staff was brilliant. The food also was delicious.”
A guest disliked“I felt that the physical plant needed some minor upgrades in terms of paint here and there or new blindes.”
Rate found Oct 2026: check cancellation terms.Full profile of Coral Sands Hotel: rooms, photos and reviews
ConsiderOnly 45 guest reviews so far
One Ocean Drive
A guest liked“Interior of the room and whole hotel, beautiful location, several restaurants available at the property, spa centre”
A guest disliked“Food was really average and extremely expensive”
Also considerNo rate found when prices were checked.
Full profile of The Ocean Club, A Four Seasons Resort, Bahamas: rooms, photos and reviews
Queen's Highway , BS, Gregory Town 1548, Bahamas
A guest disliked“Service and quality of food on the restaurant”
Also considerNo rate found when prices were checked.
Full profile of The Cove Eleuthera: rooms, photos and reviews
See the hotel page for room types.
Restaurant #1
The Potlatch Club Boutique Hotel Old Banks Road, Governor's Harbour, Eleuthera, Governorʼs Harbour, Bahamas
Also considerNo rate found when prices were checked.
Full profile of The Potlatch Club: rooms, photos and reviews
No hotels match all of these filters.
Areas as listed for each hotel. Prices are the lowest nightly rates found in Oct 2026.
3
$1,095
$21,406
1 with 1 Key
The Island House has the highest guest score in this selection among hotels with 50 or more reviews: 9.0 from 161 reviews.
The lowest nightly rates found in Oct 2026 (2 adults) range from $1,095 to $21,406. The median is $2,220 a night. Prices change with dates.
3 of the 6 hotels hold a Michelin Key: 3 with 1 Key.
3 of the 6 list a swimming pool: The Island House, Coral Sands Hotel and The Potlatch Club.
Nassau, with 3 of the 6 hotels, followed by Gregory Town (1) and Harbour Island (1).
Hotels are ordered by guest score, then by number of reviews. Guest scores, ratings, facilities and room types come from verified guest reviews and hotel listings on our booking partner; Michelin Keys, room counts and starred restaurants from the Michelin Guide; other awards link to their source in each hotel's details. Prices are indicative: the lowest nightly rate found for 2 adults when rates were checked in Oct 2026. Choose your dates in the bar above to see live prices. Data updated 10 October 2026.
