Guests

Prices shown are the lowest nightly rate found in Oct 2026, 2 adults. Pick your dates and press Check prices for live prices.

Luxury hotels in Key West

5 of the highest guest-rated luxury hotels in Key West. Compare them by area, guest score, facilities and price.

Indicative rates
$513 to $544 a night
Updated
10 October 2026
Filter hotels
Area
Facilities

5 hotels

Sort hotels by

5 hotels in Key West, ranked by guest score

Downtown Key West

H2O Suites- Adults Only

Highest guest score on this list: 9.3 from 397 reviews. Guests rate the location 9.3, third-highest here.

  • Outdoor pool
  • Adults only

ConsiderNo rate found when prices were checked

9.3Wonderful · 397 reviewsLocation 9.3
Check datesno rate found Oct 2026
Check availabilityView hotel

Downtown Key West

The Gardens Hotel

Second-highest guest score on this list: 9.2 from 87 reviews. Guests rate the location 9.7, the highest here.

  • 2 pools

ConsiderOnly 87 guest reviews so far

9.2Wonderful · 87 reviewsLocation 9.7
Check datesno rate found Oct 2026
Check availabilityView hotel

The Capitana Key West

Joint third-highest guest score on this list: 9.1 from 2,843 reviews. Value for money rated 8.5 by guests, third-highest here.

  • Outdoor pool
  • Beachfront
  • Family rooms
9.1Wonderful · 2,843 reviewsLocation 8.8
$544a night, indicative
Check availabilityView hotel

Downtown Key West

Santa Maria Suites Resort

Joint third-highest guest score on this list: 9.1 from 623 reviews. Guests rate the location 9.4, second-highest here.

  • Outdoor pool
  • Family rooms

ConsiderNo rate found when prices were checked

9.1Wonderful · 623 reviewsLocation 9.4
Check datesno rate found Oct 2026
Check availabilityView hotel

The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West

Value for money rated 8.6 by guests, second-highest here.

  • 2 pools
  • 3 restaurants
9.0Wonderful · 465 reviewsLocation 8.7
$513a night, indicative
Check availabilityView hotel

Luxury hotels in Key West: questions

What is the highest-rated luxury hotel in Key West?

H2O Suites- Adults Only has the highest guest score in this selection: 9.3 from 397 reviews.

How much does a luxury hotel in Key West cost?

The lowest nightly rates found in Oct 2026 (2 adults) range from $513 to $544. The median is $544 a night. Prices change with dates.

How this list works

Hotels are ordered by guest score, then by number of reviews. Guest scores, ratings, facilities and room types come from verified guest reviews and hotel listings on our booking partner; Michelin Keys, room counts and starred restaurants from the Michelin Guide; other awards link to their source in each hotel's details. Prices are indicative: the lowest nightly rate found for 2 adults when rates were checked in Oct 2026. Choose your dates in the bar above to see live prices. Data updated 10 October 2026.